Equations over universal algebras: some old and new surprises
Abstract:
Solving equations is in the center of algebra and has induced several
new number systems and algebraic structures. In the variety of
commutative rings with identity, any solution of a polynomial
equation p = 0 is also a zero of any polynomial in the ideal (p)
generated by p; hence we might speak of "the zero of an ideal". Let
us call an equation (or a system of equations) over a ring R
"sovable" if there exists an extension ring S which contains a
solution of this equation (of these equations). Hence x^2+1=0 is
solvable over the reals.
A version of the Nullstellensatz answers the question when a
polynomial equation p=0 over R is solvable in this sense: this is the
case iff (p) has zero intersection with R. So p = 2x+1 = 0 is not
solvable over the integers modulo 4 since p^2 = 1.
If we leave this well-known (?) variety, we face lots of surprises.
For instance, x^2+1=0 has uncountably (!) many solution in the
Hamiltonians. If A ¾ B, an equation which is solvable over A need not
(!) be solvable over B, and every system of equations in a variety
has either no solution, or precisely one, or the number of solutions
exceeds every given cardinal in a suitable extension - a dramatic
contrast to the case of fields.